A My Twinn and American Girl Doll Comparison – Which Is Better?

So, back in April when my parents were talking about giving me a blog, I had been doing a lot of research on the differences between My Twinn and American Girl. So, my mom assigned me (as part of my homeschooling) to write about which one was better and which one wasn’t as great. I decided to post on my blog, so I hope you enjoy reading about the differences!

American Girl dolls are made in China. My Twinn are made in the USA. American Girl dolls are $115-$120 for a ready made doll, complete with one outfit and a pair of shoes. My Twinn dolls are $100 for a completely customizable doll with one outfit, shoes and socks, and a tank and brief set. Which one sounds like a better deal? American Girl? No? Didn’t think so.

So, according to that information, My Twinn is better. But if you’re like me, then you’ll say: “But American Girl has more clothing options. And they have historical clothing! Plus, you can’t tell exactly what your My Twinn doll will look like.”

So, now you’re really confused. They are both good and bad. American Girl only has 18″ dolls and My Twinn has both 23″ and 18″.  A lot of people are not happy with American Girl though, because they have mainly Caucasian dolls.

In some areas, My Twinn is clearly better, and in some, AG is.

Cost

AG definitely has the higher price. My Twinn’s has much better prices.

 

Made in….

The AG dolls are all made in China, out of vinyl that may or may not be phthalate free. My Twinn dolls are made, designed, and assembled in the U.S.A.  They are also made from lead-free, phthalate free vinyl.

 

Customizable-ness

The My Twinn dolls are completely customizable. AG has a lot of dolls to choose from, but the only customizable feature is choosing whether or not they have earrings or a hearing aid or not.

 

How Many Times the Dolls Go On Sale

American Girl really only has decent sales for Cyber Monday and the occasional Jill’s Steals and Deals sale. My Twinn has one happening almost all the time, which makes getting a doll much cheaper and easier. I feel that they have better return and pricing policies, as well.

 

Pictures on the Website

When you order an American Girl Doll, the doll in person will look exactly how it looks online. For My Twinn custom dolls, you have no idea exactly how they are going to look or how the hair, eye, and skin combos will look.

 

Quality

Both are very nice dolls with an equal quality.

 

Clothing, Accessories, and Furniture

American Girl has many more options, often trendier and brighter. My Twinn has some cute options, too, but they might not appeal to as many 8-12 year olds. They sure do appeal to me, though!

 

Comes With . . . 

American Girl Dolls come with an outfit, small hair accessory, shoes, and socks. My Twinn dolls come with one outfit, hair ribbons, tank and brief set, shoes, and socks.

 

Hair

American Girl Dolls have wigged hair. My Twinn dolls are wigged. If you wanted to customize a doll with something that neither of the doll brands offer (i.e. purple hair) then both  dolls could work.

 Here is a great review of a My Twinn doll.

Here is one of an American Girl doll by the same person.

All in all, I think that both are good. It really depends on what you want in each individual doll and what you care about in toy manufacturing.

I personally feel better supporting My Twinn, and I hope that people agree with me.

 

Kathleen

 

 

26 comments… add one
  • Noelle

    Just so you know, My Twinn Dolls do not have half wigged hair. They have a piece sewn in to their wigs so that you can part the hair in multiple places, like American Girl Dolls Kailey and McKenna.

    • kathleen

      Thanks! I corrected it. 🙂

      Kathleen

  • You’re homeschooled too?? Awesome, I didn’t know that! 😀
    Have you always been homeschooled? I used to go to a public school, but I’ve been homeschooled for the past 4 years already. It’s so much fun. 🙂
    *Sunny

    • Yep!
      I’ve done homeschool and public school, but have been homeschooling for the last two years.

      • Alyse

        I have been homeschooled all my life! I have never even stepped into a school!

  • LiS

    I bought 3 custom full price My Twinns. They arrived beautifully and very happy. I bought 2 dolls ( one for each of my children and the 3rd for one of their friends as a gift). They are stored away form sun, etc. My children take excellent care of these dolls. But after barely one year old, their eyes are turning PINK and My Twinn customer service says it’s no longer guaranteed. The dolls are old. A one yr old doll is not OLD!! These eyes turned pink because of poor quality used. And terrible customer service.

  • Adrianna

    I have a My Twinn doll that is 23″ and the only thing I hate about that is I can’t AG products for me. And by me, I mean the doll.

  • Donna S

    My daughter is now 19 yr old. She has a My Twinn doll and two American Girl dolls from when she was little. Both have held up extremely well over the last 12 years. No complaints on either and her My Twinns dolls eyes never turned pink. We are holding on to all of them for her daughter some day. 🙂

    • My Twinn dolls are pretty cool! So sweet that you’re saving the dolls for her own daughters. 🙂

      Kathleen

  • lisa

    my daughter has a my twinn. she will be 30 in December and so the doll it probably 25 years old. It had brown eyes originally and now they are purple. They should pay to fix them.

  • Grace

    I got a My Twinn doll about five years ago and I had only played with it for a couple months when it got harder to pose it because the wire got stiffer and really creaky. Although American Girl is more expensive I like them more. I don’t like what they did recently with the historical dolls because they no longer have historically correct clothing.

  • Casey Dryden

    I have a Samantha AG from 1995, she has held up beautifully, no issues with her eyes and I played with her constantly. I also got a MyTwinn around 1999 and she has also held up well. She has brown eyes that have stayed brown and she has the bendable body which is nice. My only complaint is that the hair gets ruined on both dolls with brushes that aren’t wire (and most kids don’t pay attention to that at younger ages). It’s awesome that you’re homeschooled btw! I’m 25 now and plan to homeschool my daughter!

    • I’m glad to hear that they both held up well! Yes, the hair can be unfortunate. Oh, cool!

  • Robert Parsons

    I purchased 2 Twin dolls for my granddaughters one year ago. They look amazingly similar to my girls. This was the reason I wanted the Twin vs. American Girl. American Girl dolls only look like whatever the manufacturer decided, not custom made to look like your child. They love how the dolls look like them! I was well pleased with the quality. I have not had any issues whatsoever with the quality or the eyes. The eyes look exactly the same as when fresh out of the box.
    I would like to buy more clothes for the dolls and can not find the My Twin website any longer. Did they close their business?

    • Yes, unfortunately My Twinn closed. Do you have 18″ or 23″ dolls? There are shops on Etsy that sell clothes for both 18″ and 23″ My Twinn dolls. And the 18″ dolls should be able to wear any American Girl, Our Generation, Springfield, etc. clothes.

  • Kathleen

    I bought a my twinn doll that was totally posable about 28 years ago and the doll weather well the eyes are brown like my daughter and they are still brown ( dolls eyes) I’m very happy with the doll. My name is also Kathleen

    • Hi Kathleen! 🙂
      I’m glad the doll lasted so well.

  • Brenda

    There is NO comparison, NONE!. I am so biased. Almost all dolls are special to the individual beholder, however, the My Twinn cannot be compared. I remember the response of my grand daughters when they received their look-alikes. They were astounded. AGs are fun but are not as nearly identical as the MT. I do concede in that the newer dolls and more recent owners may have altered some of the composition, and certainly don’t have the options that I had when picking out my grand daughters’ keepsakes. What a memory I have of these MTs and their owners. Priceless!!!
    Oh, MT was about 2-1/2 times the price of AG years ago when I purchased the MTs. Ahh, and so well worth it.

    • I’m glad to hear that you love My Twinn dolls so much!

  • Tanya

    We love our my twinn doll it looks like my daughterand favor me we took it to Disney World and eveyone stop us

  • Rachel

    I was given a Twinn doll (with a matching outfit set for myself and the doll) when I was 4-5, it is now currently about 25 years old. It is in impeccable (seriously, almost new) condition despite having been played with during my childhood and withstanding many moves and time in storage. My daughter is now the same age I was when I was gifted the doll and loves playing with it – we purchased infant clothing which gives it an updated clothing look and fits the doll perfectly. No discoloration in the doll whatsoever – it is truly a product of great quality.

    Sidenote: fantastic project and comparison Kathleen! What a fantastic idea – hopefully you c

    • Wow! It’s great to hear that they hold up well. I do wish My Twinn had been able to stay open!

      Thank you!

      Kathleen

  • Tornesia

    I am looking for a Mt Twinn doll do anyone no if they are going to open their business. Or a business that makes dolls to look like you? Hoping for the best.

    • As far as I am aware, My Twinn has no plans to re-open their business.

      Here are a few other ideas: https://www.thespruce.com/top-look-alike-dolls-775033.

      Many people will also customize American Girl or similar dolls to look more like a certain person or character. You can search “american girl custom doll” and look at the images that come up. There are several Etsy shops who will customize a doll based off of a photo.

      Best of luck!
      Kathleen

Leave a Comment

%d bloggers like this: